How many bikes is too many
Moderators: Bearbonesnorm, Taylor, Chew
How many bikes is too many
Well I've just pulled the trigger on a Genesis tour de fer 20. That puts me up to 7. Anyone any experience with the tour de fer
-
- Posts: 8144
- Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 9:56 am
Re: How many bikes is too many
I'm currently holding at 6.
I could maybe 'justify' a CX bike too......
I could maybe 'justify' a CX bike too......
Re: How many bikes is too many
5 here, plus one with an engine
Only reason I can't get anymore is I've run out of space...
Only reason I can't get anymore is I've run out of space...
Re: How many bikes is too many
Oh counting engine one too then I can add 1
Re: How many bikes is too many
I've got 6 (jumpy MTB, xc bike, fatty, cx bike, roadie, bmx) and while i could easily have more (a dh bike and/or a trials one) 6 seems to be quite a lot already...
Pre-kids, i had more than this, although often in bits!
Pre-kids, i had more than this, although often in bits!
- TheBrownDog
- Posts: 2108
- Joined: Thu Mar 14, 2013 8:46 pm
- Location: Chilterns
Re: How many bikes is too many
I had to ask myself with question a couple of years ago. It was getting silly. I had nine of the things and only ever rode three of them. So Ive sold off six bikes in the past two years, keeping a rigid 29er for bikepacking, my Fatty and a Whyte 901 for when I want to get rowdy.
The one bike I wish Id kept was my Condor Pista fixie. Not to ride. Just to look at. It was a thing of beauty and I genuinely miss it.

The one bike I wish Id kept was my Condor Pista fixie. Not to ride. Just to look at. It was a thing of beauty and I genuinely miss it.

I'm just going outside ...
Re: How many bikes is too many
5 ish ( there is a 6th that is hung up for sentimental reasons but too small and needing a refurb).
5 should really be 4 though but the Cotic didn't sell.
I have had 7 at one point though.
5 should really be 4 though but the Cotic didn't sell.
I have had 7 at one point though.
-
- Posts: 1267
- Joined: Wed Apr 03, 2013 8:46 pm
- Location: Edinburgh
- Contact:
Re: How many bikes is too many
I'm currently on 6, with one incoming and looking to sell two. So technically 7 for a while, unless anyone wants to buy my fat bike?
-
- Posts: 697
- Joined: Wed Apr 10, 2013 4:53 pm
- Location: Cheshire
Re: How many bikes is too many
8 here
Summer Road
Winter Road
Vaya
Fargo
Singlespeed
9
7 Fat
Krampus
Whyte T130s
Summer Road
Winter Road
Vaya
Fargo
Singlespeed
9
Krampus
Whyte T130s
- JohnClimber
- Posts: 4101
- Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2012 10:41 pm
Re: How many bikes is too many
5 this morning, ref aboveAlasdairMc wrote:I'm currently on 6, with one incoming and looking to sell two. So technically 7 for a while, unless anyone wants to buy my fat bike?

Use discount code Johnc20 to get 20% off Crofto Cycling Clothing
Website - https://crofto.com.au/
Website - https://crofto.com.au/
Re: How many bikes is too many
HTbenp1 wrote:5 here, plus one with an engine
Only reason I can't get anymore is I've run out of space...
Rigid SS
Gravel bike turned into a commuter
Brompton
Road bike turned into a flat bar SS pub bike
I'd like a road bike, a cargo bike, and a gravel bike
Then maybe other fun ones like FS, e bike, fat bike etc
- metalheart
- Posts: 482
- Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2016 8:56 pm
- Location: Escocia
Re: How many bikes is too many
Currently numbering 6 (plus one with an engine) but... The Soul is getting handed on to the Loon (who hasn't currently a bike and I'll probably be selling the CX to a mate who seems to have taken a shine to it.
I should really dispense with one of the chubbies but they have been the most recent additions. So no chance of that!
The roadie hasn't seen action for over three years, should really get rid of that.
And the motorbike is definitely on a shoogly peg atm. Expensive extravagance that has been superseded by bikepacking in the main...
I should really dispense with one of the chubbies but they have been the most recent additions. So no chance of that!
The roadie hasn't seen action for over three years, should really get rid of that.
And the motorbike is definitely on a shoogly peg atm. Expensive extravagance that has been superseded by bikepacking in the main...

Give the dirt a little room.
Re: How many bikes is too many
2 is plenty for me.
1 x jones plus for offroad
1 x disc trucker for commutes/tours. tho this is up for sale. being replaced by a sturdier surly.
1 x jones plus for offroad
1 x disc trucker for commutes/tours. tho this is up for sale. being replaced by a sturdier surly.
- BigdummySteve
- Posts: 2974
- Joined: Sun Nov 20, 2016 9:16 pm
- Location: Somewhere over the rainbow
Re: How many bikes is too many
One, according to the Mrs 

We’re all individuals, except me.
I woke up this morning but I’m still in the dark
I woke up this morning but I’m still in the dark
-
- Posts: 8144
- Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 9:56 am
Re: How many bikes is too many
Or use it? Pitlochry. Sunday morning....metalheart wrote:The roadie hasn't seen action for over three years, should really get rid of that.
- RIP
- Posts: 9676
- Joined: Wed Nov 12, 2014 7:24 pm
- Location: Surfing The Shores Of Sanity Since 1959
- Contact:
Re: How many bikes is too many
If this wasn't BBB I'd suggest this was turning into a willywaving(*) contest
Bickerton folder (1983)
2 x Bromptons (1998, 2012)
Dawes rigid MTB (1986)
Orange P7 (2007)
Canyon AL+9.0SL (2013)
Giant road thing (2010)
Mini circus clown bike (2008)
14 x various 24" MTBs (**)
8 x balance bikes (**)
(**) Ok, these are for business purposes but they're still "mine" so I reckon they count. And I *have* ridden all of them for demo purposes so that means they definitely count
(*) And no I don't propose to investigate the feminine equivalent thereof, I'll leave that to someone better qualified than me.
No idea what that total is because I've had too many beers.
'Reg'

Bickerton folder (1983)
2 x Bromptons (1998, 2012)
Dawes rigid MTB (1986)
Orange P7 (2007)
Canyon AL+9.0SL (2013)
Giant road thing (2010)
Mini circus clown bike (2008)
14 x various 24" MTBs (**)
8 x balance bikes (**)
(**) Ok, these are for business purposes but they're still "mine" so I reckon they count. And I *have* ridden all of them for demo purposes so that means they definitely count

(*) And no I don't propose to investigate the feminine equivalent thereof, I'll leave that to someone better qualified than me.
No idea what that total is because I've had too many beers.
'Reg'
"My God, Ponsonby, I'm two-thirds of the way to the grave and what have I done?" - RIP
"At least you got some stories" - James Acaster
"A little nonsense now and then is relished by the wisest men" - WW
"At least you got some stories" - James Acaster
"A little nonsense now and then is relished by the wisest men" - WW
- voodoo_simon
- Posts: 4324
- Joined: Fri Apr 26, 2013 9:05 pm
Re: How many bikes is too many
In coming around to this idea, one for work and commuting and another bike (in my case, singlespeed commuter and rigid, geared 29er for fun stuff).ton wrote:2 is plenty for me.
1 x jones plus for offroad
1 x disc trucker for commutes/tours. tho this is up for sale. being replaced by a sturdier surly.
Currently don't use my fatbike, winter road bike, spare 26" singlespeed mountain bike and my aero road bike. Also have several frames knocking about too, all pointless.
Shame they don't carry any second hand value that would make the above worth passing on

- gairym
- Posts: 3151
- Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2012 11:05 am
- Location: Chamonix, France (but a Yorkshire lad).
Re: How many bikes is too many
I'm currently on 8.5 of the little buggers (and use them all).
They are (in ascending order of tyre size):
- Road bike (Planet X Super Pro SL)
- Pub bike (Planet X Kaffenback SS)
- Dave Marsh 80's road frame/forks (ongoing restoration project of love - I lived across the road from Dave's shop growing up but could never afford one of his bikes)
- Gravel frankenbike (Cotic Escapade)
- 26" hardtail (Cotic Soul)
- 29er rigid (On-one Lurcher)
- Bouncy bike (Santa Cruz Blur LT)
- 29+ (Singular Rooster)
- Fatty (Travers Bat Fastard)
I justify them as there's very little overlap in use. I could quite easily do without the Soul but I'd get so little for it that I might as well keep it and arguably I don't need a 29er and 29+ but they're quite different beasts.
I plan on switching the Lurcher for a Solaris as/when a used frame magically appears and at some point in the future I'd like to replace the bouncy bike with one with bigger wheels but that'll only happen when the Blur dies.
Usually I buy used frames and always build up the bikes recycling bits and getting old/used/sale parts so it's not as extravagant as it might first appear - honest!
I love bikes!!!!!
They are (in ascending order of tyre size):
- Road bike (Planet X Super Pro SL)
- Pub bike (Planet X Kaffenback SS)
- Dave Marsh 80's road frame/forks (ongoing restoration project of love - I lived across the road from Dave's shop growing up but could never afford one of his bikes)
- Gravel frankenbike (Cotic Escapade)
- 26" hardtail (Cotic Soul)
- 29er rigid (On-one Lurcher)
- Bouncy bike (Santa Cruz Blur LT)
- 29+ (Singular Rooster)
- Fatty (Travers Bat Fastard)
I justify them as there's very little overlap in use. I could quite easily do without the Soul but I'd get so little for it that I might as well keep it and arguably I don't need a 29er and 29+ but they're quite different beasts.
I plan on switching the Lurcher for a Solaris as/when a used frame magically appears and at some point in the future I'd like to replace the bouncy bike with one with bigger wheels but that'll only happen when the Blur dies.
Usually I buy used frames and always build up the bikes recycling bits and getting old/used/sale parts so it's not as extravagant as it might first appear - honest!
I love bikes!!!!!
- metalheart
- Posts: 482
- Joined: Sat Jun 25, 2016 8:56 pm
- Location: Escocia
Re: How many bikes is too many
Skinny tyred freaks...metalheart wrote:
The roadie hasn't seen action for over three years, should really get rid of that.
Or use it? Pitlochry. Sunday morning....

Give the dirt a little room.
- whitestone
- Posts: 8210
- Joined: Thu Dec 04, 2014 10:20 am
- Location: Skipton(ish)
- Contact:
Re: How many bikes is too many
I feel left behind
MTB: Cotic Solaris
Fat Bike: Singular Puffin
Road bike: Specialized Roubaix
Commuter/winter bike: Genesis Croix de Fer
In vitro is an One One Pompetamine that will at some point become a single speed

MTB: Cotic Solaris
Fat Bike: Singular Puffin
Road bike: Specialized Roubaix
Commuter/winter bike: Genesis Croix de Fer
In vitro is an One One Pompetamine that will at some point become a single speed
Better weight than wisdom, a traveller cannot carry
- In Reverse
- Posts: 1855
- Joined: Mon Oct 12, 2015 9:08 pm
- Location: Manchester
Re: How many bikes is too many
3 for ages:
Just built a rigid SS titanium mtb to add to the fleet so 4 now.
Truth be told if I could find a decent 140mm straight steerer fork I'd manage just fine with the Ogre for everything. That ship's well and truly sailed though.
I suspect I might well buy a Vir Fortis at some point...
- Surly Ogre for touring & bikepacking
Charge hardtail for XC and winter bikepacking
A bouncy full sus for smashing about in the Peaks and Lakes with mates.
Just built a rigid SS titanium mtb to add to the fleet so 4 now.
Truth be told if I could find a decent 140mm straight steerer fork I'd manage just fine with the Ogre for everything. That ship's well and truly sailed though.



I suspect I might well buy a Vir Fortis at some point...
-
- Posts: 2154
- Joined: Wed Mar 21, 2012 9:39 am
- Location: Southern Cataluña
- Contact:
Re: How many bikes is too many
My name is Pistonbroke and I'm a bikeaholic.
No seriously, together Mrs PB and I have 13 in full working order.
Her, PLanet X TT bike with carbon frame, wheels, tri bars, tubs.
Focus Cayo road bike with Di2
Ribble Scouro Aero road bike with Mavic wheels.
Orange Clockwork 29er
On One Dirty Disco with Digest bars,Shimano 2x11 road hydraulic gruppo, Stans wheels setup tubeless
Me, Litespeed Tuscany Ti with full Ultegra 11 speed gruppo and Dura Ace C24 wheels.
Van Nicholas Redwood Ti 29er with Rohloff hub and bikepacking kit inc Dynamo, Stans wheels, Carbon On One OG bars.
On One Lurcher Carbon 29er with full XT and Fox forks.
On One Lurcher with Alfine 11 hub gear.
On One Scandal with single speed setup which is actually 4 speed.
SAB Crosser with Dynamo hub and Gravel wheels and tyres.
Giant XTC Team carbon that I won the National Trailquest Championship on, can't bear to be parted from it.
Santa Cruz Blur LT with Hope brakes and wheels, lovely.
All are ridden fairly regularly but I must admit the gravel bikes are getting the most use at the moment.
The bloke at the bank didn't believe us when we wanted to get them insured so we had to take pictures.
No I'm not saying where we live.
No seriously, together Mrs PB and I have 13 in full working order.
Her, PLanet X TT bike with carbon frame, wheels, tri bars, tubs.
Focus Cayo road bike with Di2
Ribble Scouro Aero road bike with Mavic wheels.
Orange Clockwork 29er
On One Dirty Disco with Digest bars,Shimano 2x11 road hydraulic gruppo, Stans wheels setup tubeless
Me, Litespeed Tuscany Ti with full Ultegra 11 speed gruppo and Dura Ace C24 wheels.
Van Nicholas Redwood Ti 29er with Rohloff hub and bikepacking kit inc Dynamo, Stans wheels, Carbon On One OG bars.
On One Lurcher Carbon 29er with full XT and Fox forks.
On One Lurcher with Alfine 11 hub gear.
On One Scandal with single speed setup which is actually 4 speed.
SAB Crosser with Dynamo hub and Gravel wheels and tyres.
Giant XTC Team carbon that I won the National Trailquest Championship on, can't bear to be parted from it.
Santa Cruz Blur LT with Hope brakes and wheels, lovely.
All are ridden fairly regularly but I must admit the gravel bikes are getting the most use at the moment.
The bloke at the bank didn't believe us when we wanted to get them insured so we had to take pictures.
No I'm not saying where we live.
-
- Posts: 405
- Joined: Wed Dec 31, 2014 10:31 am
Re: How many bikes is too many
Only 3
On One Horizontal Dropout rigid 26 for bikepacking MTB
Specialised Langster Fixed for commuting
Giant TCR 1 road bike which I never use (probably for sale if anyone's interested ;-)
On One Horizontal Dropout rigid 26 for bikepacking MTB
Specialised Langster Fixed for commuting
Giant TCR 1 road bike which I never use (probably for sale if anyone's interested ;-)
-
- Posts: 824
- Joined: Sun Oct 18, 2015 12:15 pm
Re: How many bikes is too many
I'm down to four
Boardman hybrid for road
Kona Cindercone ss 22 year old fun
Jones steel spaceframe for mtb
And ramin 3 plus for sale
Boardman hybrid for road
Kona Cindercone ss 22 year old fun
Jones steel spaceframe for mtb
And ramin 3 plus for sale
-
- Posts: 114
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2011 4:00 pm
Re: How many bikes is too many
7 between the missus and me, 2 PX Pro Carbon's, On One Lurcher, On One Inbred, 2 On One Pompino's SSCX, and a fixed On One Macinato, all built up from just the frame or frameset with nice kit but not quite the same as saying you have 7 Sevens like I saw somewhere on a bike forum a while ago!